Europe Is Redrawing Farm Subsidies Again. Here's Why the Smartest Farmers Never Let a Government Cheque Be Their Business Plan.

9 hours ago

10 min read

Update (October 2026): The UK just cut fertiliser tariffs. Here's why it won't save your farm, and what will.

Farmer at his gate holding a torn government letter while families pick apples at his farm, showing visitor income outlasting farm subsidy changes

At 10 a.m. on 22 September 2026, England opened the second window of its Sustainable Farming Incentive. The pot was £233 million.

Within hours, three-quarters of it was spoken for. By 3.48 p.m. the window was shut. About 12,200 applications got in. Everyone else was told to try again in 2027.

Five weeks later, Europe's 27 farm ministers met in Luxembourg to rewrite the rulebook that pays Europe's farmers for 2028 to 2034.

Different countries. Same lesson. The cheque you count on can change shape, shrink or vanish at a meeting you are not invited to.

The short answer: On 26 October 2026, EU farm ministers agreed their position on the post-2027 Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), but left the money out. The European Commission wants farm funding folded into single national and regional partnership plans, with at least €300 billion ring-fenced for income support and market crises. Today's CAP is €386.6 billion, but that figure also covers rural development, which would now have to compete with other spending inside each country's plan. The UK and the US are rewriting their farm payments too. The farms that ride out these changes have income no politician controls: paying visitors, direct customers and a list of buyers they own.

What just happened in Luxembourg

On 16 July 2025, the European Commission proposed the biggest shake-up of farm funding in decades.

Today, the CAP has its own two funds: one for income support and markets, one for rural development. The Commission wants to merge farm money into one "National and Regional Partnership Plan" per country, sitting alongside other EU spending. It ring-fenced at least €293.7 billion for income support plus a €6.3 billion "Unity Safety Net" for market crises. The separate rural development fund would disappear, replaced by a target of at least 10% of each country's non-ring-fenced plan money for rural areas.

Farm groups were furious. Copa-Cogeca, the umbrella group for EU farmers and farm co-operatives, said it was shaping up to be the "worst reform of the CAP." On 18 December 2025, Brussels police counted about 1,000 tractors and 8,000 people in the streets.

The European Parliament pushed back too. On 23 October 2026, Socialist MEPs welcomed a shift by the centre-right EPP's lead negotiator and renewed their call for a dedicated CAP plan inside each national plan, with rural development money protected.

Farmers' tractors lined up in a row during a protest — Illustrative photo, not the Brussels protest. Photo: Ieva Brinkmane, Unsplash.

Then came the ministers' meeting on 26 and 27 October. Chaired by Ireland's farm minister Martin Heydon, they agreed a "partial negotiating position." In plain English: they agreed the rules, but not the money. The budget fight moves to the EU's wider 2028 to 2034 budget talks.

Italy's farm minister, Francesco Lollobrigida, set out his red lines. He objected that the draft drops an option Italy uses today: putting 3% of direct payments into a national mutual fund that pays out after droughts, floods and frosts. He also asked for proper funding of the €6.3 billion safety net.

Read that again. A G7 country had to argue to keep the way its farmers fund their own weather-disaster safety net.

The pattern nobody tells you about

This is not a one-off. Europe has rewritten its farm support rules again and again since 1962.

Timeline of EU Common Agricultural Policy reforms from 1962 to the 2028-2034 proposal — Europe has rewritten its farm support rules again and again since 1962.

Price support began shifting to direct payments in 1992. Payments were cut loose from production in 2003. "Greening" arrived in 2013. A new model with national strategic plans started in 2023. Now comes 2028.

At the same time, farming's slice of the EU budget keeps shrinking.

Bar chart showing the CAP share of the EU budget falling from 73% in 1980 to about 15% in the 2028-2034 proposal — Farming's share of the EU budget has fallen from almost three-quarters to a proposed one-seventh.

And that money matters. The Commission's own figures show that from 2018 to 2022, subsidies made up about a third of EU agricultural income, with direct payments alone about 23%. In Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia, direct payments topped 40%.

When a third of your income depends on rules that change every few years, you do not have a business. You have a policy bet.

It's not just Europe

The UK: the cheque is almost gone

England has been phasing out its Basic Payment Scheme since 2021. The cuts were sped up in the October 2024 Budget. In 2025 the most any farm could receive was £7,200. In 2026 and 2027 it is £600. The government says 2027 is the last year.

The replacement scheme, SFI, closed with immediate effect on 11 March 2025 when its budget ran out. Then came the six-hour scramble in September 2026.

Add inheritance tax. From 6 April 2026, full relief applies only to the first £2.5 million of farm and business property per person (raised from £1 million after farmers protested in Westminster), with 50% relief above that.

Here is the good news hidden in Defra's own data. In 2024/25, 72% of English farms had diversified income. Diversification brought the average farm £22,400, the biggest single slice of farm income, and more than farming itself.

Bar chart of average English farm business income in 2024/25 split into diversification, agri-environment, agriculture and basic payments — On the average English farm, diversification now earns more than farming itself.

In 2020/21, basic payments made up 55% of English farm business income. By 2024/25 it was 19%. The farms that built other income in between are the ones still smiling. You can see that resilience in the British Farming Awards 2026 winners.

The US: more aid, less certainty

America is going the other way, but no more predictably. USDA forecasts direct government payments of $47.4 billion in 2026, up from $27.9 billion in 2025. That would top the $45.6 billion paid in 2020, the previous high in cash terms.

More than half of the 2026 total, about $26.5 billion, is one-off aid. Most of it comes from a $12 billion package announced on 31 December 2025, which includes $11 billion of Farmer Bridge Assistance. That followed up to $10 billion of emergency ECAP payments in 2025 for 2024 crop losses. Meanwhile, the extension of the 2018 farm bill expired on 30 September 2026 with no replacement passed.

One-off aid is exactly that: one-off. As we showed with the $8 billion fuel relief plan, a bailout patches this year. It does not build next year.

Where	What changed	When	What it means for you
European Union	Farm money folded into national plans; €300bn ring-fenced, rural development must compete	Proposed July 2025; ministers' position Oct 2026	Rules agreed, money still undecided
England	Basic payments capped at £600 a farm, ending after 2027	2026 to 2027	The old cheque is almost gone
England	SFI closed suddenly, then reopened for just hours	March 2025; September 2026	Schemes can shut without warning
UK	Full inheritance tax relief capped at £2.5m per person	From April 2026	Succession plans need a rethink
United States	Record total payments forecast; farm bill extension expired	2025 to 2026	Big cheques, no long-term promise

Europe's own rulebook still says: diversify

Here is the part most news reports skip.

The Commission's 2028 to 2034 proposal names "agro-tourism" as a way farms can diversify their income. Its LEADER rural programme names agrotourism too. And the ministers' text agreed in Luxembourg keeps support for farm diversification, "for instance through agrotourism."

Europe is cutting the cheque and pointing at the gate.

Stone farmhouse on a Tuscan hill above a vineyard, the kind of farm that hosts agritourism guests — Illustrative photo, not a specific agriturismo. Photo: Wolfgang Hasselmann, Unsplash.

Italy shows what that looks like at scale. In 2024 it had 26,360 authorised agriturismi, hosting 4.7 million guests, 54.8% of them from abroad. Ismea values the sector at about €1.9 billion. We unpacked that in our Italy agritourism lessons.

On the Maltese island of Gozo, young farmers used €150,000 of EU rural development money toward a €442,584 agritourism project. In its first year it welcomed about 4,200 visitors and created two full-time jobs.

That is the smart way to use a government cheque: as seed money for income you will own, not as a salary you hope keeps coming.

Reality Check: Visitor income is not risk-free. Weather, insurance, local planning rules and bad reviews can all hurt. The difference is who holds the controls. You can fix a bad price, a slow website or an empty weekend. You cannot vote on the next CAP.

Why visitor income rides out a policy change

Diagram comparing a subsidy-dependent farm with a visitor-income farm when farm payment rules change — Same policy change, two very different farms.

Family picking apples together in a pick-your-own orchard — Illustrative photo, not a specific farm. Photo: Land O'Lakes, Inc., Unsplash.

Visitor income has four things a subsidy never will.

You set the price. If your fuel and feed go up, your ticket can too.

You own the customer. An email or WhatsApp list goes with you through every reform.

You get paid early. Bookings, deposits and season passes put cash in your account before the season starts.

You decide the timing. A farm stay, a pick-your-own day or farm event can fill the months when crops earn nothing.

The numbers back it up. US farms earned $1.26 billion from agritourism and recreation in 2022, up from $949 million in 2017, as we break down in our agritourism statistics guide. Australian farmers even have a name for it: drought-proofing.

5 moves to make before the next rewrite

Field-Tested Play No. 1: Work out your "cheque share." Divide last year's subsidy and aid income by your total profit. If it is over 30%, a single policy change can take a big bite out of your margin. Write the number down. It is your starting line.

Field-Tested Play No. 2: Start one small paid visitor test this season. Not a barn conversion. One farm tour, one pick-your-own weekend, one tasting. Our 60-minute test shows how.

Field-Tested Play No. 3: Build a buyer list you own. Every visitor gives you a name and a phone number or email. Our email marketing guide shows what to send them.

Field-Tested Play No. 4: Use grants as seed, not salary. If you take public money, spend it on something that earns for years, like the Gozo farm did. See our list of agritourism grants and funding.

Field-Tested Play No. 5: Sell direct while food prices are high. Families are driving to farms to buy. Our guide to farm direct sales shows how to keep the retail price.

What my durian farm taught me about this

My farm, Bloopy Durians in Bentong, Malaysia, has short seasons: about four to five months of durians a year, from December to February and June to August.

So I could never wait for a cheque. Instead, we built income we control. Visitors come from all over the world to eat durians under the trees. Many companies send their staff and management to the farm, and we supply durians for corporate events.

Our most reliable income is a WhatsApp list of loyal customers who buy whenever durians are ready. No minister can redesign that list.

Questions to ask before you diversify

This is not legal or tax advice. Rules differ by country. Take these questions to your adviser.

Planning: Do I need permission for visitors, parking, toilets or a farm stay? Our guide to farm venue zoning shows how it can go wrong.

Scheme rules: If I use land for visitors, does it stop counting for area-based payments or agri-environment agreements?

Tax: In the UK, could a tourism business change how inheritance tax relief applies to my land? Elsewhere, how is visitor income taxed? Start with our agritourism tax questions.

Insurance: Does my farm policy cover paying guests? Most do not. Read our agritourism insurance guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the CAP 2028-2034 proposal?

It is the European Commission's plan for EU farm funding from 2028. It folds farm money into one national and regional partnership plan per country, with at least €300 billion ring-fenced for farmers, including a €6.3 billion market crisis safety net.

Did EU ministers agree the new CAP in October 2026?

They agreed a partial negotiating position at their 26 to 27 October 2026 meeting in Luxembourg. It covers the rules, not the budget, which will be settled in the EU's wider 2028 to 2034 budget talks and negotiations with Parliament.

Will EU farm subsidies be cut?

Farm groups fear so. Today's CAP is €386.6 billion across two funds. The proposal ring-fences at least €300 billion for income support and market crises, while rural development money would have to compete inside each country's wider plan. The final budget is still being negotiated.

Does the EU still support agritourism?

Yes. The Commission's proposal names agro-tourism as a diversification option, and the ministers' October 2026 text keeps support for diversification through agrotourism.

When do UK farm payments end?

In England, delinked basic payments are capped at £600 per farm for 2026 and 2027, and 2027 is the final payment year.

How can a small farm reduce its dependence on subsidies?

Start one small paid visitor activity, build a customer list you own and sell direct. Take our quiz below to see which fits your farm.

Find out if your farm is ready

Governments will keep rewriting the cheque. The question is whether your farm can stand on its own when they do. Take the free Farm Readiness Quiz to see which visitor income fits your land, your time and your budget.

Take the Farm Readiness Quiz

Then download the free 21-Point Agritourism Blueprint to plan your first step.

Get the Free 21-Point Blueprint

P.S. About 12,200 applications made it in before the six-hour SFI window slammed shut. Thousands of farmers missed out. The farmer with paying visitors did not need to sit by the screen at 10 a.m. Build that income now, before the next window slams shut.

By Stephen Loke of AgritourismSuccess.com, whose farm is featured in Bloomberg News and Asahi Shimbun. This article is for general information only and is not legal, tax or financial advice.