Fair Isn't Always Equal: How to Split the Farm Between the Child Who Farms and the Ones Who Don't

1 day ago

12 min read

A grown daughter by a tractor, her two siblings on a farmhouse porch, and their father at a table with scales and papers at sunset

In 2014, an accountant, Angela Heyes, and her engineer husband Neil left their home in Surrey and moved to a family farm near Truro, in Cornwall. The farm had a livery business and a glamping site with a yurt. They say her parents promised the farm would one day be theirs.

Her father died in 2020. By 2024, the couple were in the High Court of England and Wales against her mother, with her two siblings on the mother's side. The judge said the couple's case was weak, but he let it go to a full trial. He urged the family to settle, and he warned that a loss could ruin the couple. He compared the dispute to "a modern-day King Lear." I could not find a report of a final result.

Nobody in that family set out to fight. They hoped, and hope is not a plan.

The problem is a simple one. One child farms. The others don't. The farm is worth far more than anything else the parents own. So how do you split it so that the child who farms can keep farming, and the children who don't still feel they were treated with love and respect?

The short answer: Fair does not have to mean identical slices. A fair split usually gives the farm to the child who farms, gives the other children cash, insurance or other assets of comparable value, and puts four things in writing: a will, a buy-sell agreement, each person's role, and any past gifts or unpaid wages. The rules depend on your country, your state and sometimes your religion. So treat this article as a list of questions for your lawyer, not as legal advice.

Why Equal Slices Can Sink the Farm

Most parents say the same thing: "We love all our children the same." So they divide everything three ways and feel good about it.

Then the farm has three owners, and only one of them gets up before sunrise.

Here is a real case from Minnesota. A couple ran a dairy farm on two parcels of land. In 1995 they put both parcels into a trust with their three children as equal beneficiaries. In 2004 their daughter and her family bought the herd, leased the land, moved onto the farm and converted it to organic.

Both parents had died by 2012. The three children now owned the farmland in equal shares. In 2015 one sibling asked a court to divide or sell it.

Two court-appointed referees looked at the land. They found it could not be divided without great harm to the daughter who farmed. They recommended giving her both parcels, crediting her $119,000 for her improvements, and having her pay her siblings $387,667 between them.

The trial court set that aside and ordered the land split into equal thirds. In 2018 the Court of Appeals of Minnesota reversed that decision and said the referees' report deserved more weight.

The parents treated their children equally. The farming daughter still ended up in court, fighting to keep farming.

Reality Check: In a 2006 survey of Iowa farmers, about 40 percent said the best farm estate plan was to divide everything equally among all the heirs. Extension specialists at the University of Minnesota give an example where cutting a farm into three equal pieces leaves each slice too small to run as a viable business.

Equal can feel safe. But equal is not the same as fair. Farm insurers have a saying for this: "fair doesn't mean equal."

Three Questions to Answer Before You Split Anything

Before you draw any lines on a map, answer these three questions on paper. Your family will argue less when they see real numbers.

Question No. 1: How much of our wealth is the farm?

For many families, the answer is most of it. The land is worth a lot, but it is not cash. You cannot hand a sibling a third of a field to pay for a house deposit.

Question No. 2: What has each child put in, and what were they paid?

Extension specialists at the University of Wisconsin ask pointed questions. Is the child who farms paid a fair market wage? Or do they take a low wage on the promise that things will be "made right" in the will? And is that arrangement written down?

A promise that lives only at the kitchen table is a classic seed of a farm fight.

Question No. 3: What does each child need?

One child may have received college fees or a house deposit years ago. Another may be raising children on one income. The University of Minnesota lists early gifts like these as common reasons families treat heirs unequally, and still fairly.

Field-Tested Play: Make a one-page ledger. List every child down the side. Across the top, write: years worked on the farm, wages actually paid, gifts or loans already received, and what each child says they want. Share it at a family meeting. Surprises are cheaper to find now than in a courtroom.

The Four-Piece Fair Split

Most good farm transfer plans have the same four pieces. Think of them as four legs of a table. Remove one and the table wobbles.

Piece No. 1: The farm goes to the child who farms.

University of Minnesota Extension says to start transferring some assets early, so the child who farms can begin building the business and feel some pride of ownership. A handover does not have to wait for a funeral. Parents who sign a transition plan do not have to stop farming the day they sign it.

Piece No. 2: Everyone else gets something of comparable value.

The children who don't farm can receive non-farm assets. That might be cash, savings, other property, retirement accounts or life insurance. Insurers and extension offices call this "equalizing" the inheritance.

Life insurance is the tool you will hear about most. The parents buy a policy and name the non-farming children as beneficiaries. When the parents die, the cash arrives without anyone having to sell a field.

Reality Check: Life insurance is not for everyone. The parents have to be insurable, and premiums rise with age. One published farm estate example had a yearly premium of $60,000, and the family decided it could not afford it. University of Minnesota Extension says to treat insurance as one strategy among several, and to never buy more than you need or can afford.

Piece No. 3: A buy-sell agreement sets the price and the terms.

A buy-sell agreement is a written contract. It says who can buy what, at what price, on what schedule, and what event triggers the sale. University of Wisconsin Extension lists death, disability, retirement and sometimes divorce as typical triggers.

Extension specialists in Minnesota say a well-made agreement can bind the spouse and the non-farming heirs. It gives the child who farms a clear price and clear terms. It gives the other children a price they can trust. Insurers note that these agreements often help avoid a forced sale or a cash crunch.

Piece No. 4: Written roles.

Who runs the farm? Who keeps the books? Who has the final say? Who is paid, how much, and when? This piece is so often skipped that it gets its own section below.

Tool	What it does	A question to ask your lawyer
Will or trust	Says who gets what after you die	Does it give any one child the power to force a sale of the land?
Lifetime transfer or gift	Moves part of the farm to the farming child early	What are the tax and family-law effects of giving it now?
Life insurance	Creates cash for children who don't farm	Who should own the policy, and who should be the beneficiary?
Buy-sell agreement	Sets the price, terms and triggers for a buyout	Will it bind the spouse and the other heirs?
Long-term lease	Lets a non-farming heir keep a link to the land	Can the farming child hold a first right to buy?
Written roles and pay	Records who does what and who earns what	How do we document past unpaid work and wages?

Written Roles: The Part Everyone Skips

Families will argue for years about who gets the barn. Then they never write down who is supposed to run it.

Write down every job. If you run farm tours, a farm shop, events or a farm stay, include those too. Visitor income often creates more than one role: a booking manager, a marketing lead, a finance person, a guide. Our article on When Siblings Inherit the Family Farm but Not the Vision shows how siblings with different skills can each hold a real, paid role.

Field-Tested Play: Write a one-page role sheet for each person. Include the job title, hours, pay, who decides what, and what happens if that person quits, falls ill, divorces or dies. Date it, sign it, and review it every year. When you review it, update the ledger from the section above too.

Pay the child who farms a fair wage now. A child who works for years at a low wage in return for a promise is building a claim that may be hard to prove later. That is exactly the kind of claim that ends up in front of a judge.

The Will Problem: 47 Percent Don't Have One

Here is the number that should make every farm family sit up.

The Irish farm accounting and advisory firm ifac surveyed about 860 Irish farmers for its Irish Farm Report 2022. It found that 47 percent of farmers did not have a will. Two in three had no succession plan.

The number has improved since. Later ifac reports put it closer to two in five. That is progress, but it still means a large share of farming families are leaving the decision to the law.

When there is no will, the law fills the gap. University of Wisconsin Extension warns that in the United States the result is often the state's default plan, which divides assets equally among heirs. That is the Minnesota story all over again.

Bar chart showing 47 percent of Irish farmers had no will, two in three had no succession plan, and about 40 percent of Iowa farmers favored an equal split — Numbers from the ifac Irish Farm Report 2022 and the 2006 Iowa FARMTRANSFERS survey, as reported by Ohio State University.

A will is not the whole plan, either. Farm Progress makes the same point: a will or trust is one part of a full succession plan. The buy-sell agreement, the insurance and the written roles do the rest of the work.

Land Rich, Cash Poor: How Visitor Income Helps

This is where agritourism changes the math.

The hardest part of any fair split is the shortage of cash. The farm is worth a lot, but the farm does not hand out cash. So the child who farms ends up owing siblings money that the farm cannot produce.

A farm that earns from visitors has more to work with. Here are a few ways families use that income:

Fund the equalizing payments. Tours, events or farm stays can create steady cash for the child who farms to pay a buyout over time. See our guide to how to start a farm tour business.
Give a non-farming sibling a paid role. A brother who lives in the city may be great at marketing, bookings or accounts. He can earn a fair wage without owning an acre. Our piece on farm kids as tour guides shows how younger family members can start.
Rent a building instead of forcing a sale. A sibling who wants an income from the land can lease a barn or building for events. See how to rent out farm buildings.
Protect the parents' income too. Parents need money in their later years. Read retirement income for farmers and agritourism for older farmers before anyone signs over everything.

At Bloopy Durians in Bentong, Malaysia, where I am the founder, the farm welcomes visitors from all over the world, and many companies send their staff and management to visit. The farm also has a WhatsApp list of loyal customers who buy durians whenever they are available. That is income built on people, not only on trees. A farm that earns from visitors and repeat buyers has more than land to divide.

Reality Check: Every one of these ideas has insurance, tax and zoning effects. Before you hand a family member a paid role or lease a building, read what agritourism insurance coverage you need and agritourism and taxes: questions to ask your accountant. Then ask your own advisers.

If You Farm in Malaysia, Ask These Questions First

Inheritance rules in Malaysia differ by religion. That makes the lawyer's questions even more important. I am not a lawyer, so use this section as a list of questions, not answers.

Here is the basic picture. For Muslims, an estate is generally divided under faraid, the Islamic law of inheritance. For non-Muslims, the Distribution Act 1958 applies when there is no will, and the Wills Act 1959 governs wills. Muslim families often ask about wasiat (a bequest, generally limited to one-third of the estate) and hibah (a gift made during life).

Which law applies to our family and to our land?
If one of our heirs follows a different faith, how does that change who can inherit?
Can I leave more of the farm to the child who farms, and how far can a will change the shares?
Can I gift part of the farm during my life, and what happens to that gift when I die?
What court or office handles our estate, and how long does it usually take?

The same kind of question applies elsewhere. In the United States, rules differ by state. In the United Kingdom, inheritance tax rules for farms have changed, and our article on the 2026 farm inheritance tax changes explains the latest. In Canada, our Saskatchewan farm succession guide is a good place to start.

10 Questions to Bring to Your Lawyer, Accountant and Insurance Broker

Print this list. Take it to every adviser. Ask each one to answer in plain words.

Which law governs my estate, and does it change by my family's religion, state or country?
Can I leave the farm to one child and other assets to the rest? Can the others challenge that?
What does the law do if I die without a will?
How should the farm be valued, and by whom?
Which assets, besides the farm, can I use to equalize shares?
Is life insurance right for us, who should own the policy, and what will it cost?
What should a buy-sell agreement say about price, payment terms and triggers like death, disability or divorce?
How do I record years of low or unpaid work by the child who farms?
What are the tax effects of giving part of the farm now versus leaving it in the will?
How do I stop one heir from forcing a sale of the land?

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it legal to leave the farm to only one child?

In many places, yes, but there are limits. Some countries and states let children who are left out, or left very little, make a claim against the estate. Maurice Blackburn, an Australian law firm, describes these as family provision claims. Ask your lawyer what the rules are where you live.

How do I know what the farm is worth?

Get an independent valuation from a qualified appraiser. In the Minnesota case, the family used an agreed appraisal and appointed referees to review it. A neutral number lowers the temperature in the room.

What if the child who farms cannot afford to buy out the others?

A buy-sell agreement can spread payments over many years. An installment sale is one way to do this. Life insurance, income from visitor activities and a long lease are other ways to ease the burden.

What if my non-farming children want to keep a link to the land?

Some families give them a long-term lease, a house, a small plot, or a share of income. The child who farms can hold a first right to buy. Ask your lawyer which of these fits the law where you live.

What if no child wants to farm?

Then the conversation changes from "who gets the farm" to "what do we want the farm to become." Our articles on farm succession planning and the farm succession conversation cover both.

When should we start?

Now. A farm dispute mediator in Cork told The Irish Times that the earlier families talk about wills and succession, the better. Start with a dinner and a notebook.

Your Next Step

You now know the four pieces: the farm for the child who farms, comparable assets for the others, a buy-sell agreement and written roles. Your lawyer will build the legal side.

The part I can help with is the income side. In a one-hour consultation session (US$150), we look at what visitor income your farm could realistically earn, so the child who farms has a real business to run and your family has cash to make the fair split work. Bring your lawyer's questions list. I will bring the agritourism numbers.

Book Your Consultation Session

Not sure where your farm stands? Take the Farm Readiness Quiz first.

Take the Farm Readiness Quiz

Want ideas for earning more from the land you already own? The free ebook 150 Ways to Unlock Hidden Wealth From Your Farm shows 150 ways farms can add income, with a focus on visitors and using what you already have.

Get the Free Ebook: 150 Ways to Unlock Hidden Wealth From Your Farm

P.S. Angela and Neil Heyes say they moved their family for a promise. Whatever your family decides, write it down this winter, while everyone is still talking to each other.

Stephen Loke of AgritourismSuccess.com, whose farm is featured in Bloomberg News and Asahi Shimbun. This article is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Inheritance law differs by country, state and religion, so speak with a qualified lawyer before you act.