Defra Just Scrapped 'First Come, First Served' for SFI27. Don't Let Your Farm's Income Hang on the Next Rule Change

Philip Weston farms in Northamptonshire. He expected a Sustainable Farming Incentive agreement worth about £110,000 over three years. Then an error on one field blocked his application. Farmers Weekly reports he is now considering spring beans instead.
In Somerset, Tim Smith was travelling when the window opened. When he tried to apply, he was told it had closed. He estimates he has lost £60,000 of income over three years.
Neither man's problem was bad farming. It was the way the queue worked.
Now Defra has said it will drop "first come, first served" for SFI27. That is good news. But nobody has told you how SFI27 will work, how big the budget will be, or whether your farm will get in. So the sensible answer is simple: keep applying where you can, and stop letting one scheme decide your year. Build at least one income stream that depends on your visitors, not on a rule book.
The short answer: Farmers Guardian reported on 11 November that Defra will scrap first come, first served for SFI27 and is weighing other methods. The rules, budget and opening date were still unpublished at the time of writing. Keep applying, but add income you control: a farm shop, a farm stay, school visits or events. |
What Defra Actually Said About SFI27
On 11 November, Farmers Guardian reported that Defra will scrap the first come, first served model for SFI27 after "the issues seen with this year's iteration". The farming minister, Stephen Morgan, was speaking at the AIC conference in Peterborough. He confirmed to the paper that Defra is considering various methods for next year.
This did not come out of nowhere. On 21 October, Mike Rowe, Defra's acting director general for food and farming, told a Tenant Farmers Association webinar that ministers had committed to moving away from first come, first served. He said Defra is aiming to launch the next SFI in 2027.
Here is what is still missing. As far as we could find on 18 November 2026, Defra had not published the SFI27 budget, the full rules or an opening date. Scrapping a method is not the same as announcing a scheme.
What Went Wrong in SFI26, in Numbers
The numbers explain why farmers are so anxious. Window 2 of SFI26 opened at 10am on Tuesday 22 September and closed at 3.48pm the same day.
What happened | The figure |
Window 2 opened | 10am, Tuesday 22 September 2026 |
Window 2 closed | 3.48pm, the same day |
Applications received in Window 2 | About 12,200 |
Extra potential applicants officials estimate may have wanted in | More than 10,000 |
Money committed across both windows | £310m |
Cap on each application | £100,000 |

Defra says the £310m will deliver £930m of environmental investment over three years. It also argues the £100,000 cap was needed because a quarter of earlier SFI funding had gone to just 4% of claimants.
Mike Rowe told MPs on 27 October that Defra knew the SFI26 budget was finite and unlikely to meet demand. The Rural Payments Agency's grants director, Tom Foster, also said that in many cases the system had blocked applications correctly, for example because of mapping issues.
Reality Check: Scrapping first come, first served removes the race. It does not add money. If SFI27 demand again outruns the budget, someone still misses out, only by a different rule. The budget has not been announced. |
Five Ways Defra Could Choose Who Gets In
Mike Rowe listed the options under consideration. These are options, not decisions, so treat the right-hand column as forecasts, not facts.
Option under consideration | What it could mean for your farm |
Screen applications up front and set a priority order | Who you are may matter as much as when you apply |
Score applications on what they would deliver | A well-prepared plan could beat a fast click |
Fewer actions on offer, as in SFI26 | Fewer menu items to build your income around |
Lower payment rates and area limits on some actions | The same land could pay less |
A rethink of the overall cap (£100,000 in SFI26) | Larger agreements could shrink |
The NFU has its own list. It says around £1 billion is needed, that about £960 million a year is being freed up as older agreements expire, and that about 48,000 farmers in England are eligible to apply for an SFI27 agreement. It wants SFI27 to open in early 2027, with agreements starting on 1 April.
Those are the union's asks and estimates, not Defra's promises. Planning a farm business around an ask is how farms get hurt.
How to Be Ready for Whichever Method Defra Picks
You cannot control the rules, but you can control how ready you are. A few jobs are worth doing now, whatever Defra decides.
Check your land and maps. The Rural Payments Agency's grants director said the system blocked many SFI26 applications correctly, for example because of mapping issues. Fix any parcel or boundary problems well before a window opens.
Know your support route. SFI26 had an "assisted digital" group, for farmers who needed the RPA to complete an application for them. If that is you, ask early how to get help.
Keep your plan flexible. Fewer actions or lower rates are both on the list of options. Do not build next year's cash flow on one action paying a set amount per hectare.
Keep records of what your land delivers. If applications are scored on what they would deliver, that is a forecast, not a promise. Notes, photos and maps cost you little and could help.
None of this guarantees a place. It only means that if the door opens, you are not the farmer trying to find a boundary map at 3pm.
And while you wait, put your energy where the rules are yours to write.
The Real Risk Is Not the Queue. It Is Renting Your Income
Scheme income is rented income. Someone else sets the rules, and they can change between one year and the next.
You have already seen it happen. SFI closed abruptly to new applicants in March 2025, and Defra's Secretary of State later admitted mistakes were made. It came back in 2026 with a £100,000 cap and two windows. Now the way of choosing who gets in is being rewritten for 2027.
We have seen the same pattern elsewhere. When Europe redrew its farm subsidy rules again, the lesson was the same: never let one cheque be the whole plan. And when the Budget kept the family farm tax, farms learned that policy can change the numbers overnight.
Scheme income | Visitor income | |
Who sets the rules | A government department | You |
Who decides if you get in | A budget, a system and a selection method | Your customers, one at a time |
What can change next year | Budget, rates, caps, windows | Your prices, opening days and offer |
What it costs to start | Application time, maybe an agent | Set-up costs, which vary widely |
Main risk | Rule changes | Weather, disease closures, a slow start |
That last row matters. Visitor income is not risk free. It is risk you can plan for, price for and insure against, which is very different from waiting for someone else's decision.
What English Farms Already Do, in Defra's Own Numbers
You would not be the first. Defra's Farm Business Survey found that 72% of farm businesses in England had some diversified activity in 2024/25.
The most common choice was letting out buildings, at 50% of farms. Solar came next, at 27%. Farms with diversified activities earned an average of £31,100 of enterprise income from them.
For 26% of those diversified farms, the diversified income made up at least half of their farm business income. That is not a side hustle. For many farms, it is the business.

Reality Check: Averages hide wide gaps. Letting buildings pays well on average, but it is not a visitor business. Tourist accommodation and catering averaged £8,700 for farms that do it, and sport and recreation averaged £3,600. Your own numbers will depend on your farm, your location and your prices. For a wider list, see our guide to the top seven ways English farms diversify. |
Three Visitor Income Streams You Control
You do not need a theme park. You need one stream where you set the price and the opening hours.
1. A Farm Shop
Rob and Heather Copley returned to Ravensknowle Farm near Pontefract to stop it being sold. Rob has described the farm before the shop as an arable and dairy farm "not making a lot of money".
The shop opened on 12 December 2003 with a small butchery counter and a few shelves. By 2026 the farm was growing more than 300,000 pumpkins for its festival, and its tulip festival tickets started from £8. You can read the full story in our Farmer Copleys case study.
Field-Tested Play: Start with one counter, not one building. A few shelves of your own produce tells you what customers will pay before you spend a penny on a barn. |
2. A Farm Stay
Crown Cottage Farm near Skipton lists a shepherd's hut at £95 a night with a two-night minimum. Our guide to starting a farm stay walks through set-up costs, nightly rates and permit questions.
Here is an illustration, not a forecast. If one hut were booked for 60 nights at £95, it would bring in £5,700 before costs.
3. School Visits and Events
Barleylands in Essex lists a guided school visit at £14.50 per child, excluding VAT. Another illustration: eight visits of 30 children would be 240 children, or £3,480 before VAT and costs.
At the other end, Furtho Manor Farm near Milton Keynes lists a high-season Saturday for a barn wedding at £5,750 for 2027 and 2028.
Farm | What visitors pay |
Crown Cottage Farm, near Skipton | £95 per night, two-night minimum |
Knepp Estate, West Sussex | Most safaris £75 |
Barleylands, Billericay | £14.50 per child for a guided school visit (ex VAT) |
Furtho Manor Farm, near Milton Keynes | £5,750 for a high-season Saturday barn wedding |
Cotswold Lavender, Snowshill | Adult £7.75 peak |
Prices are as listed on each farm's own website, checked on 6 November 2026. You will find 30 more in our list of UK agritourism examples and in the 50 best farms to visit in the UK.
Field-Tested Play: Your 90 Days While SFI27 Is Decided
Do both. Scheme money is real money. The point is to stop it being the only money.
Days 1 to 14: Write down your rented income. List every payment that depends on a scheme and the rules behind it. Keep every SFI and Countryside Stewardship option you can still apply for alive.
Days 15 to 45: Pick one visitor stream. Choose the one that fits your buildings, land and energy. Test it with ten paying guests before you invest.
Days 46 to 90: Price it, protect it and open small. Ask your insurer, your council and your accountant the questions below. Then open on your quietest weekends.
Think about how you will be found, too. Our guide to agritourism marketing ranks ten channels by what really brings visitors.
Questions to Ask Before You Open to Visitors
This is general information, not legal advice. These are the questions to ask, not the answers.
Planning: Does my plan need planning permission, or does a permitted development right apply? Changes that took effect on 21 May 2024 doubled the floorspace that can change from agricultural to flexible commercial use, from 500 to 1,000 square metres. Those rights do not usually cover external building works, and local policy can be stricter. Ask your local planning authority or a planning adviser.
Insurance: Does my current policy cover paying visitors? Open Farm Sunday asks hosts for at least £5 million of public liability cover, which is a useful benchmark. Public liability is not a legal requirement, but employers' liability is if you employ staff. Ask your insurer in writing.
Safety: Have I carried out a risk assessment? The Health and Safety Executive says those running animal visitor attractions have a legal duty to assess risk. Our guide to hidden farm hazards for visitors is a good checklist to start with.
Rates and tax: How will a shop, café or stay change my business rates and tax position? See how a farm shop or café could pay zero business rates, then ask your accountant.
Shutdowns: What is my plan if disease or weather closes the gate? Read what a foot-and-mouth closure would do to farm visitor income and what one storm weekend cost a pumpkin farm.
A Lesson From a Durian Farm in Bentong
I am the founder of Bloopy Durians in Bentong, Malaysia. I run durian farm tours there, and the farm welcomes visitors from all over the world. Many companies send their staff and management to visit.
The most valuable thing I have built is not a field or a licence. It is our WhatsApp list of loyal customers who buy durians whenever they are available. It is a reliable source of income, and nobody had to approve it.
You can build your own version. Every visitor who enjoys your farm is a future customer, and every customer you can message directly is income no scheme can close.
Questions English Farmers Are Asking About SFI27
Has Defra confirmed SFI27 will not be first come, first served?
Farmers Guardian reported on 11 November that Defra will drop that model for SFI27. Mike Rowe also said on 21 October that ministers had committed to moving away from it. What replaces it has not been confirmed.
When will SFI27 open?
Defra is aiming to launch the next SFI in 2027. The NFU wants it to open in early 2027, with agreements starting on 1 April. As far as we could find, no opening date had been confirmed on 18 November 2026.
How big will the SFI27 budget be?
It has not been announced. The NFU says around £1 billion is needed. Across both SFI26 windows, £310m was committed.
Should I stop applying to SFI and focus on visitors?
No. Scheme money can pay for real environmental work on your land. The aim is to add income you control, not to walk away from income you can win.
How much can a farm earn from visitors?
It varies widely. In Defra's 2024/25 survey, farms with tourist accommodation and catering averaged £8,700 from it. Some farms in this article charge far more per booking, but prices are not profit. Work out your own costs first.
Do I need planning permission for a farm shop or farm stay?
It depends on the building, the land and your council's policy. Some changes of use can be done under permitted development rights, and others need an application. Ask your local planning authority before you spend money.
What if my farm is not in England?
Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland run their own schemes, so SFI27 may not apply to you. The logic is the same, though. See how Scottish farms are facing the same support squeeze.
Build the Income You Control, Starting With One Plan
If you want a step-by-step way to open your farm to paying visitors, start with The First-Season Profit Plan. It is a 39-page PDF workbook with four modules, from scouting your 40-mile market and choosing your launch season, to budgeting year one and getting your insurance, permits and emergency plan in place.
You also get six printable worksheets, a 12-week countdown checklist and an Opening Day Scorecard, a go or no-go test before you take your first booking. It costs $37 as a one-time payment, with a 30-day money-back guarantee. The method works outside the US, but you must check planning, insurance and quotes locally.
Not sure your farm is ready? Take the Farm Readiness Quiz to see which areas to fix first.
Want ideas before you spend anything? "150 Ways to Unlock Hidden Wealth From Your Farm" is a free 150-page ebook. It gives you 150 money-making ideas in 10 categories, plus 15 quick wins you can start for $5,000 or less, a 90-day launch roadmap and a break-even formula. Each idea shows difficulty, start-up cost, price set-up and yearly earning potential.
P.S. Philip Weston and Tim Smith did not run into trouble because of bad farming. They ran into a rule. Whatever Defra decides for SFI27, build one income stream where you set the rules.
Stephen Loke of AgritourismSuccess.com, whose farm is featured in Bloomberg News and Asahi Shimbun. This article is general information, not financial, legal or insurance advice. Check scheme rules, planning, tax and insurance with a qualified adviser for your own farm.
Sources
First come first served scrapped for SFI27 (Farmers Guardian, 11 November 2026)
Sustainable Farming Incentive 2026: The haves and have-nots (Farmers Weekly, 2026)
Defra considers ways to avoid another SFI debacle (Farmers Weekly, 22 October 2026)
NFU demands £1bn SFI27 budget after SFI26 chaos (Farmers Weekly, November 2026)
NFU calls for £1bn SFI27 budget to meet farmer demand (NFU, 11 November 2026)
DEFRA to rethink SFI application process after race against time and system (Farmers Guide, 24 September 2026)
Defra weighs SFI27 changes after backlash over 2026 scheme (FarmingUK, 24 September 2026)
Analysis: SFI returns in 2026, but doubts linger (Farmers Weekly)
Defra knew SFI budget wouldn't meet demand, MPs told (Farmers Weekly, 27 October 2026)
Cross-party MPs demand answers over SFI26 chaos (Farmers Weekly, September 2026)
Farm Accounts in England: Chapter 5, Diversification (Defra, updated 12 May 2026)
Planning red tape slashed for farmers (GOV.UK, 21 May 2024)
Farm diversification: reform to permitted development rights (Trowers & Hamlins)
Health and safety guidance for Open Farm Sunday events (Open Farm Sunday)
Health and safety regulator reminds farmers to keep visitors safe and healthy at open farm events (HSE, 6 June 2025)
Farm prices as listed on each farm's own website, checked 6 November 2026, as compiled in our UK agritourism examples guide.




Comments